There is definite proof that sustainability-focused funds are outperforming their conventional counterparts. But some experts believe the traditional explanations for this are wrong.
How many deals has Citigroup closed in this space?
Citigroup closed two deals since we created a special group to pursue opportunities in this space. In calendar 2005 we completed Rain Industries and Shetron.
Why did Citigroup decide to enhance its focus on this area?
The Corporate Debt Restructuring (CDR) mechanism was introduced along with legal powers given to lenders through a securitisation act and the establishment of asset reconstruction companies. Both were instituted for the first time in India. Lenders now have the ability to insist on a restructuring of their stress assets which is creating dealflow.
What were the deal parameters of the deals you did?
Rain Industries (erstwhile Priyadarshini Cement) was done under the aegis of the CDR. The company issued Rs1128 million ($25.4 million) of new debt to Citigroup which Rain used to pay down existing debt. Citigroup also picked up equity warrants in Rain Commodities (the parent company). Shetron was not a CDR case but a private take out. We invested about $10 million.
What drove your investment decision in each case?
A driver of doing the Rain deal for Citigroup was familiarity and comfort with the sponsor. A bullish cement sector outlook, fuelled by India¦s burgeoning infrastructure and housing sectors, made this an attractive sector to have exposure to. The ongoing consolidation in India's fragmented cement industry and the potentially attractive valuation with the increased M&A activity in the sector represented an added positive.
Shetron is a company in the metal packaging business. This was a small deal by our normal standards but the deal parameters and ShetronÆs business prospects were attractive enough to kindle our interest.
What is the most critical input into your investment decision?
While sector is an important input, it is the quality of promoter and management which is paramount for us.
What do you think will drive your business in this area?
We believe there is significant potential to turn around companies in India but expectations of existing lenders on settlement values need to be carefully managed. The other critical aspect is pricing. Unlike equity markets where pricing can be benchmarked against transaction multiples, the debt market - which is still evolving - has few precedents for pricing buyouts.
Does Citigroup have an annual India allocation for this product?
We do not have an allocation but we are hopeful of closing 3-4 deals annually with an average deal size between $15-50 million.
Is your focus in India the same as elsewhere in Asia?
The focus in India is somewhat different to what is being done in China - ie. it is on single deals and not debt portfolios.
What are the risk factors and how do you seek to mitigate these?
The most significant risk is the lack of a well defined exit. India does not yet have an active market for trading corporate paper and if the company does not perform as anticipated the debt may not reach the credit rating required to make it tradeable. We typically address this by ensuring we have the necessary ammunition (for example clauses triggering conversion of debt into equity in case of default) to force a change in control should the situation deteriorate.
What is your view on the market going forward?
We have a strong deal pipeline and are cognisant that India deals will require a flexible approach to structuring and closures will be slow due to the complexity involved. WeÆre bullish on the product in the long term.
AsianInvestor reveals the first half of our marquee winners for this year's Asset Management awards, including best asset service provider and top alternative fund houses.
The number of millionaires in mainland China grew by 35% in 2020, while the number of millionaires in Hong Kong fell by 7%, according to a new report from the private bank.
The Australian pension fund joins other asset owners in eyeing private credit opportunities in the Asia-Pacific region, although liquid defensive assets retain a majority of allocations.
Alternatives news roundup: Asia Pacific's alternatives market to hit $6tr by 2025; Indonesia's SWF to buy troubled toll roads
Asia Pacific alternatives market to grow to $6tr by 2025; Australian private capital assets rose to A$77 billion in mid-2020; Chinese authorities limit cash management products holding riskier securities; Indonesia's sovereign wealth fund to acquire several toll roads; Korean institutional investors support scheme to buy US asset-backed securities; and more.